I've long been a critic of Colbert and the drafting. He gets these accolades (sp?) for being this drafting master, but the results are far from that. The 2011 and 2012 drafts are still unknowns. They will play out in the next couple years. But the drafts that should be making up the core of this team, 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009, as a whole, are hardly anything to write home about.
In 2006, 2008 and 2009 combined, there's 1 player left on the roster (Ziggy Hood and people are not all that enamoured with him). In 2007, we did get Timmons and Woodley, and that certainly makes it a great draft, but having 3 starters left at this point from those 4 drafts (5 total player including Spaeth and Gay) is just not a productive output.
I'm also not thrilled with the constant high pick spending on the lines. Not that the lines didn't need help, but over the last 4 years, out of our top 8 picks, 6 have been on the line (OL/DL). It's not a surprise that our skill positions suck now. I think that was an over-reaction to the lack of attention he paid on those positions over the years. And now, as a result, we have another problem.
It can be frustrating at times, but their system is about as successful as it gets. Sure, let's get big name free agents every year like the Redskins. I hear Albert Haynesworth is available.
Defense no longer wins championships, offense does, a number 1 D will get you to 8-8 if your offense sputters!
We need to draft WR,TE,RB which ever order 1st three picks are defense will right itself.
Seeing those draft picks of Colbert/Tomlin the last few years make me miss the Tom Donahue/Cowher years of the 90's when they were KILLING it in the draft. #sarcasm
1) Charles Johnson WR
2) Brenston Buckner DT
3) Jason Gildon OLB
1) Mark Bruener TE
2) Kordell Stewart QB
3) Brenden Stai OG
1) Jamain Stephens OT
3) Steven Conley LB
3) John Whitman RB
1) Chad Scott CB
2) Will Blackwell WR
3) Paul Wiggins OT
The 90's Donahue/Cowher years were much worse. Plus I do miss all those home AFC championship games where the Steelers were double-digit favorites and choked. I guess the more time passes the more we forget.
Last edited by Reg3835; 03-29-2013 at 11:01 AM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)