How to rank QBs (an honest discussion)

[Crash]

Eli's numbers can't have the possibility of dipping when he's not consistently in the playoffs.

3 of the last 4 seasons sitting at home.

If his last name wasn't Manning he'd be Jon Kitna.

[NeilPatrickBanana]

Please. Took Peyton, the alleged most talented QB ever SIX YEARS to win a playoff game.

Not even Kordell Stewart took that long.

Wake me up when Peyton has a post season as good as 2005 Ben. Hell 2008 Ben too.

Overrated dome throwing stat whore.

BFD.

So now the amount of time it takes a QB to win a playoff game is a relevant factor? That's a good one...

Hey how do you resolve 2003?

In 2003, Peyton was having one of the ALL TIME great post seasons... he was practically flawless through 2 games.... and then came the AFC Championship game... against.... Yup the CHEATERS... He was perfect before that game... and then threw 4 picks against the Pats

I just love the predicament your arguments put you through.

Had the Cheaters, not been cheating.... would Peyton have won the Sper Bowl that year against the Carolina Delhommes?

[Crash]

Had the Cheaters, not been cheating.... would Peyton have won the Sper Bowl that year against the Carolina Delhommes?

His history says no, Peyton and his dome throwing *** has never won a playoff game with the temp 40 degrees or lower.

It was 31 that day.

You lose.

[NeilPatrickBanana]

Eli's numbers can't have the possibility of dipping when he's not consistently in the playoffs.

3 of the last 4 seasons sitting at home.

If his last name wasn't Manning he'd be Jon Kitna.

So making the playoffs consistently is relevant.... that's something Brady and Peyton always do.... Ben has missed 3 times in the last 7 years.

[Crash]

that's something Brady and Peyton always do..

Brady yes, after 2002 that is. Funny how his team missing the playoffs after winning a ring never gets mentioned.

Peyton? He missed twice in 9 years. Ben missed 3 times.

[NeilPatrickBanana]

His history says no, Peyton and his dome throwing *** has never won a playoff game with the temp 40 degrees or lower.

It was 31 that day.

You lose.

So the 10 point difference was the result of weather... and not the Cheaters knowing the playcalls resulting in 4 picks?

So going forward... weather trumps cheating.... lol

[Crash]

So the 10 point difference was the result of weather... and not the Cheaters knowing the playcalls resulting in 4 picks?

So going forward... weather trumps cheating.... lol

Did the Jets cheat before that? How about the Ravens this year?

I said it in October, yeah Peyton's winning the garbage AFC West, we'll see what he does when it's 30 in Denver in January.

And, his three turnover *** didn't let me down.

[NeilPatrickBanana]

Brady yes, after 2002 that is. Funny how his team missing the playoffs after winning a ring never gets mentioned.

Peyton? He missed twice in 9 years. Ben missed 3 times.

Peyton missed ONCE in the last 9 years.... you don't count a season in which he missed the entire year.
Just like you don't count the Matt Cassell year for Brady

Don;t be silly

[Crash]

Peyton missed ONCE in the last 9 years

I'm talking 9 years into his CAREER. Just like 2004-2012 Ben.

I'm not the NFL, I don't change the rules for Peyton's benefit.

[NeilPatrickBanana]

Did the Jets cheat before that? How about the Ravens this year?

I said it in October, yeah Peyton's winning the garbage AFC West, we'll see what he does when it's 30 in Denver in January.

And, his three turnover *** didn't let me down.

So were the Ravens lucky or was Peyton a failure?

You can't have both...