Dwyer > Mendenhall

**Forged in Steel** · 11-19-2012, 04:47 PM

The title should say: Every Steelers' RB but Mendenhall > Mendenhall

**Real Deal Steel** · 11-19-2012, 04:55 PM

So the new excuse is "Dwyer is out of shape" huh? Wow. So an "out of shape" RB is out playing an "in shape" runningback and you still insist that Mendy is better? This gets more ridiculous as it goes.

**Nolrog** · 11-19-2012, 05:21 PM

Mendenhal is the best back on the team. Dwyer is a nice compliment, but we're better off with Mendy.

**LatrobePA** · 11-19-2012, 05:32 PM

Originally Posted by Nolrog

Mendenhal is the best back on the team. Dwyer is a nice compliment, but we're better off with Mendy.

Last night? Mendy was awful, but I felt he played rusty and flat. Too much dancing.. Dwyer just wants to run people over.

**Goodfrom55** · 11-19-2012, 05:42 PM

Dwyer was clearly the most effective runner last night. I for one don't believe Mendy is close to 100% from the ACL or achilles, but is making an effort. As much as I like Mendy and I think he is the most talented RB on the roster, his lackluster play, for whatever the reason, will result in the Steelers not bringing him back next season - especially if Dwyer and Red can handle things.

**K Train** · 11-19-2012, 05:56 PM

this will be a thread every other week. 2 good backs, offer different things and will like compete for playing time...hot hand wins

**Big T** · 11-19-2012, 05:58 PM

Originally Posted by K Train

this will be a thread every other week. 2 good backs, offer different things and will like compete for playing time...hot hand wins

This...

**Goodfrom55** · 11-19-2012, 06:17 PM

Kinda of like when Sanders and Brown were rookies, 2 dogs and one bone.

Dwyer is good for ground and pound while Mendy can run it up inside AND take it to the house. Just wish he was healthy; we're not seeing the true Rashard Mendenhall right now.

**Big T** · 11-19-2012, 06:29 PM

Originally Posted by Harrison92

Kinda of like when Sanders and Brown were rookies, 2 dogs and one bone.

Dwyer is good for ground and pound while Mendy can run it up inside AND take it to the house. Just wish he was healthy; we're not seeing the true Rashard Mendenhall right now.

This. I hate all this "F*ck Mike Wallace, AB is better", "No Wallace is better", "Dwyer is so much better than Mendenhall", "No, Mendenhall is better" bullshit. Can't we all just be happy with the fact that we have good players at both positions with different but very useful skill sets that can help this team. Instead we have to play the "my dad can beat up your dad" card every f*cking week. ****'s old.

**Real Deal Steel** · 11-25-2012, 01:22 PM

Mendy out there fumbling again against the browns huh? Oh yeah...Mendy is a good as Dwyer. NOT!

Mendy is constantly fumbling. That is one of the factors as to why he isn't better.

Mendy will be allowed to leave because he clearly isn't worth the money or better then Dwyer.

If we had Adrian Peterson, do you think we wouldn't pay him? Of course we would because AP is clearly a superior talent over Dwyer. But because Mendy ISN'T the superior talent, he will be allowed to leave.

Mendy just out there fumbling and doing that stupid spin move for no reason that leaves him suspetable to fumbling.