On paper, and if Mendy is healthy, he and Dwyer are like a dream team. We just can't get both healthy at the same time.
And yes, I see Mendy going elsewhere next year.
On paper, and if Mendy is healthy, he and Dwyer are like a dream team. We just can't get both healthy at the same time.
And yes, I see Mendy going elsewhere next year.
Bleeding Black and Gold since 86'
I do like Redman in the redzone. Dwyer has a better chance of breaking a big one and then Redman can do the dirty work in short yardageOriginally Posted by Real Deal Steel
If the front office always found a way to keep the best player, then Woodson, Plaxico, Holmes............would have all retired/still be with the Steelers. The front offices of all NFL teams, and all sports teams don't/can't always keep the better player. To make this argument is foolish.
Look, you can be the Mendy supporter all you want. That's great. But I gave specifics why Mendy isn't better then Dwyer. And I stand by them. If they felt Mendy was all that, they could find a way to sign him. But because Dwyer is better and less expensive, it's a no brainer. To think anything else..is foolish.
The Steeler way...is the only way.
I want to see the O-Line dominate and just punish teams and tell them that we are going to run and you cant stop us until you bring 8 in the box; then then send all your speed at WR down the field and punish the DBS. I dont care if we run it all day and alternate both backs every other play. The result is all I care for. I was loving that performance against the Giants on the road. 5 or 6 games ago, I didnt think that was possible. Just keep improving the run game.
I agree. Just run the damn ball man!
The Steeler way...is the only way.
You're wrong. Every year teams let better players go, because they are deemed too expensive, not because the player they keep is better. Period
Fine. Whatever gets you through the nite. But I don't see other teams letting their best runningback go. Hahahahahahaha. Guess the Vikings are going to let AP go next. I guess the new contract that Arian Foster just got is a mirage too. Hahahahaaha.
Those runningbacks are kept because their the best runningbacks on those teams. So why is Mendy going to be allowed to walk? Because he isn't the best on this team.
Whatever gets you through the nite homes.
The Steeler way...is the only way.
It doesnt really matter what happens, we can run without Mendy also. Next man up as Tomlin would say
Last edited by steelchamp204; 11-11-2012 at 01:00 AM.
Dude, do you speak in anything but logical fallacies? False choices, straw men, red herrings, you have them all. No one is saying that Mendy is Foster or AP. Many are not even saying that Mendy is better than Dwyer (your merely subjective "evidence" that Dwyer is better notwithstanding). If you cannot see that teams, especially the Steelers, let better players go in free agency ALL THE TIME for cheaper alternatives, then you are completely delusional. Letting Mendy go this offseason does NOT necessarily mean that the FO believes Dwyer is better even if he is your baby daddy. Heck, he has not even beaten out Redman in Tomlin's eyes yet or they would not be sharing snaps this week.
Who was better than Woodson when he left? Eric Green? Mike Merriweather? The Steelers do not overpay (or even pay market) when they have so much depth at a position.
"If I could start my life all over again, I would be a professional football player, and you damn well better believe I would be a Pittsburgh Steeler." -Jack Lambert
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks