Secret Superstar: Isaac Redman

**Ibleedblk&gld** · 06-29-2012, 10:01 AM

Originally Posted by ChucktownSteeler

The list is nothing more than a popularity contest by fans. Ben is ranked 30 something, really take that serious?

negative, the list is voted by the players...as I previously stated...

**K Train** · 06-29-2012, 10:34 AM

because voting for for friends and team mates is way more subjective than voting for your favorite player and players on your favorite team

**Ibleedblk&gld** · 06-29-2012, 11:41 AM

Originally Posted by K Train

because voting for for friends and team mates is way more subjective than voting for your favorite player and players on your favorite team

touche (I hate your face, K)

**FeelSteel** · 07-03-2012, 08:42 AM

Originally Posted by K Train

no one who blows out a knee in the last game of the year is going to be on the top 100 list for the following year, i dont see how thats difficult to understand.

he missed out on the list the year before to darren mcfadden, and really mcfadden making over mendenhall and hillis was stupid, both out classed mcfadden by a wide margin

You do know that P. Manning was voted onto the list and he didn't throw a single pass in 2011, right? my point is Mendenhall isn't respected among the players and to me is an average RB.

**K Train** · 07-03-2012, 09:13 AM

Originally Posted by FeelSteel

You do know that P. Manning was voted onto the list and he didn't throw a single pass in 2011, right? my point is Mendenhall isn't respected among the players and to me is an average RB.

peyton manning vs rashard mendenhall is a bit different. hall of fame QB that really holds the fate of the broncos in his hand vs a 24 year old RB with a rehabbing knee