if the steelers traded with carolina for the first pick who whould you choose

**connecticutsteel** · 04-22-2011, 01:14 AM

i would take peterson or quinn

**K Train** · 04-22-2011, 09:30 AM

patrick peterson and its not even remotely close

**andyg1984** · 04-22-2011, 09:46 AM

duh..peterson ...

lets try again .. we have new englands pick at 17.. I say Phil Taylor ..

**K Train** · 04-22-2011, 09:55 AM

phil taylor might be there at 31...i say pouncey there would be the only reason to trade up

**andyg1984** · 04-22-2011, 11:10 AM

i like carimi more than pouncey and i would not take a RT at 17 .. i think carimi makes a case for the left, but could be the man at RT

**K Train** · 04-22-2011, 11:19 AM

nah i like carimi but pouncey is the better player...the dude is gonna be a probowl guard. i think the steelers should be the only team that should consider an actual trade up for him just for chemistry sake, any other team i think it wouldnt be logical.

i like carimi, i think hes a poor mans jake long....either a good LT or a studly RT, and i would definitely take him at 17

**andyg1984** · 04-22-2011, 12:07 PM

Originally Posted by K Train

nah i like carimi but pouncey is the better player...the dude is gonna be a probowl guard. i think the steelers should be the only team that should consider an actual trade up for him just for chemistry sake, any other team i think it wouldnt be logical.

i like carimi, i think hes a poor mans jake long....either a good LT or a studly RT, and i would definitely take him at 17

i like carimi a bunch and think he will ultimately be a bigger contributor to his team than mp2 .. but at the same time i think he is standing out in a weak OT class ..

okung, williams and davis were all better imo ..

but at the end of the day i am fine with staying put and taking Ras-i because i think he is easily a top 25 prospect ..

**Zachintosh66** · 04-22-2011, 11:21 AM

peterson... if someone says newton, i will hunt them down

**connecticutsteel** · 04-22-2011, 11:34 AM

well i hope no one would say newton if teams are smart he will drop out of the first round he has russell /campbell written all over him this guy has had people at his feet since high school even his dad and a lot of people said that campbell was a better qb at auburn than newton hes the tim tebow of this draft only i think tebow will end up at tight end or specials newton will never start in the nfl .nfl,com is reporting that carolina is looking to sell this pick is it worth 4 or 5 picks or some players

**K Train** · 04-22-2011, 12:17 PM

Originally Posted by connecticutsteel

well i hope no one would say newton if teams are smart he will drop out of the first round he has russell /campbell written all over him this guy has had people at his feet since high school even his dad and a lot of people said that campbell was a better qb at auburn than newton hes the tim tebow of this draft only i think tebow will end up at tight end or specials newton will never start in the nfl .nfl,com is reporting that carolina is looking to sell this pick is it worth 4 or 5 picks or some players

newton will certainly be a starter, i think hes gonna be successful as long as hes got the right coaches around him...hes like jamarcus and young tied into one, i do think he'll be better than both of them and even if hes never great im sure he'll show flashes of greatness.

hes really not THAT much unlike roethlisberger, just got a little more straight line speed