Most Overrated Prospects?

[Dobre Shunka]

youre not understanding what i am saying...Im not saying that Eric Berry is going to be better in the NFL than Ed Reed...Im saying that Eric Berry is a better prospect coming out now, than Ed Reed was when he came out in 2002...

I never once said Eric Berry would be a better pro...

I wasn't directing that @ you. I was posting rhetorically.

In fact, I agree w/ you on Berry's college resume.

[scudmissile29]

youre not understanding what i am saying...Im not saying that Eric Berry is going to be better in the NFL than Ed Reed...Im saying that Eric Berry is a better prospect coming out now, than Ed Reed was when he came out in 2002...

I never once said Eric Berry would be a better pro...

It just looks like some Steeler fans can't see past the ratbird barrier and see Ed Reed was far greater in Miami.

[K Train]

eric berry is the best DB prospect ive ever seen. sean taylor was a better prospect than reed too, it actually wouldnt be close. reed was never talked about as a top 5 pick, hes a great player one of the best ever probably but as a pro prospect he wasnt among the elite ones. berry is

[Big T]

It just looks like some Steeler fans can't see past the ratbird barrier and see Ed Reed was far greater in Miami.

absolutely not...Im actually a big Ed Reed fan...I love the way he plays

[DanRooney]

While we have no #1 receiver anymore, I'll add Arrelious Benn to this thread. We can't draft another guy who can't catch. Tate is our only option at WR.

[K Train]

While we have no #1 receiver anymore, I'll add Arrelious Benn to this thread. We can't draft another guy who can't catch. Tate is our only option at WR.

benn is overrated, but hes pretty talented. i think tate or williams or thomas would be best. not sure how id feel about gilyard or lafell at this point

[Big T]

benn is overrated, but hes pretty talented. i think tate or williams or thomas would be best. not sure how id feel about gilyard or lafell at this point

gilyard is good slot guy but we need a #1...like I said before, Im liking DeMaryius Thomas as well

[K Train]

we have a good slot guy named hines ward. i think gilyard is comparable to holmes, but i think we need to find ourselves a superstar at this point

[steelcityrockers]

we have a good slot guy named hines ward. i think gilyard is comparable to holmes, but i think we need to find ourselves a superstar at this point

Which points to Dez Bryant, if you are going purely on talent.

[K Train]

Which points to Dez Bryant, if you are going purely on talent.

bryant gets categorized with andre johnson, fitzgerald, calvin johnson and other top picks recently...im not sure he deserves that much praise