darnik44's 2008 NFL Draft Positional Rankings

[darnik44]

(THESE ARE PLAYER WHOSE PRIMARY DRAFT STOCK IS AS A KICK/PUNT RETURNER)

[steelcityrockers]

I disagree with your QB rankings

My top-10 QBs
Ryan
Brohm
Woodson
Flacco
Ainge
Brennan
Johnson
Santos
Booty
Henne



Why do you have Desean Jackson as your #2 receiver and as a player who's main value is as a return specialist?

He isn't a good WR. Probably won't be for a few more years as he is too small and very unpolished.

[darnik44]

I disagree with your QB rankings

My top-10 QBs
Ryan
Brohm
Woodson
Flacco
Ainge
Brennan
Johnson
Santos
Booty
Henne



Why do you have Desean Jackson as your #2 receiver and as a player who's main value is as a return specialist?

He isn't a good WR. Probably won't be for a few more years as he is too small and very unpolished.

Um, I think you are looking at Dexter Jackson from Appalachian St.

I agree Jackson isn't a polished receiver, but he is a playmaker. Ted Ginn went 9th overall last year and Jackson is a much better route runner and a better runner after the catch than Ginn.

I disagree with your QB rankings. I can't see how Santos, an unersized QB who faced thin competition is ubove Booty and Henne. As far as Brennan goes, I assume you didn't see the Sugar Bowl (his first real competition).

[BlitzburghRockCity]

This is a good quick reference tool when thinking about who's available at each position. Thanks Darnik !

[steelcityrockers]

Um, I think you are looking at Dexter Jackson from Appalachian St.

I agree Jackson isn't a polished receiver, but he is a playmaker. Ted Ginn went 9th overall last year and Jackson is a much better route runner and a better runner after the catch than Ginn.

I disagree with your QB rankings. I can't see how Santos, an unersized QB who faced thin competition is ubove Booty and Henne. As far as Brennan goes, I assume you didn't see the Sugar Bowl (his first real competition).

Yeah it was Dexter Jackson, my bad.

I feel that a player should not be judged by one game. Brennan is ok. He has a pretty good arm, decent accuracy, and a quick release. Henne sucks, plain and simple. He will never be a starting qb in the NFL. I probably should have Booty ahead of Santos.

[darnik44]

Yeah it was Dexter Jackson, my bad.

I feel that a player should not be judged by one game. Brennan is ok. He has a pretty good arm, decent accuracy, and a quick release. Henne sucks, plain and simple. He will never be a starting qb in the NFL. I probably should have Booty ahead of Santos.

Well, Colt Brennan weighed in at the Sr. Bowl today. He was a mere 6-2, 185. Mike Mayock today (the best draft analyst anywhere) moved Chad Henne to #2 on his QB rankings. He looked pretty good today at Sr. Bowl practice.

[steelcityrockers]

Apparently he was sick and lost weight. Anyway, I feel that Chad Henne sucks regardless of what Mayock thinks (I do agree he>Kiper)