How to rank QBs (an honest discussion)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NeilPatrickBanana

So were the Ravens lucky or was Peyton a failure?

You can't have both...

---

Peyton's performance was dreadful. He set up 17 points for Baltimore with his careless decisions with the football. I would think a man with a vast high IQ and the alleged most talented QB ever would know better.

Only a choking dog like Peyton Manning can piss away a game when his special teams handed him 14 points.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Crash

Peyton's performance was dreadful. He set up 17 points for Baltimore with his careless decisions with the football. I would think a man with a vast high IQ and the alleged most talented QB ever would know better.

Only a choking dog like Peyton Manning can piss away a game when his special teams handed him 14 points.

---

His 1st INT is completely on Decker...
His sack/fumble was a careless decision? Somehow I think you would view that play through a different lens if it were Ben (the Oline sucks!!! Stupid playcalling!!!)

His OT INT is among the worst decisions I've ever seen a franchise QB make in the playoffs... almost a mirror image of the Favre in Minny vs New Orleans a few years ago.

You have to much bias...