PDA

View Full Version : Steelers vs Browns talent for talent



Stone
10-12-2014, 08:34 AM
If you look at the talent at key positions and groups, the Steelers are head and shoulders better than the Browns.

QB.....not close
WR......not close
RB....... close but Steelers are better
TE.......Steelers easy
O line......as a unit the Steelers are better, Joe Thomas is the best of all of them

Secondary.....toss up
Corners......Browns slightly (but Haden is out)
LB........Tough call, Steelers are young and fast but sloppy
D Line.....On paper the Steelers should be better, but.....(and the Browns have a lot of injuries today)

NeilPatrickBanana
10-12-2014, 09:54 AM
If you look at the talent at key positions and groups, the Steelers are head and shoulders better than the Browns.

QB.....not close
WR......not close
RB....... close but Steelers are better
TE.......Steelers easy
O line......as a unit the Steelers are better, Joe Thomas is the best of all of them

Secondary.....toss up
Corners......Browns slightly (but Haden is out)
LB........Tough call, Steelers are young and fast but sloppy
D Line.....On paper the Steelers should be better, but.....(and the Browns have a lot of injuries today)

Wrong on a lot...

TE - Browns
OL - Browns
LB - Browns
DL - Browns
CB - Browns (with Haden out, it's a push)

QB - Steelers
RB - Steelers
WR - Steelers
S - Steelers

ChucktownSteeler
10-12-2014, 10:45 AM
How I see it:


TE - Close, but after Heath the Steelers don't have much depth. Push
OL - Browns - The Browns have a solid OL - They have the edge. Our interior is solid, our tackles - not so much.
LB - Browns - I think we have the edge, especially with Krueger out.
DL - Browns - Overall Browns have the edge, but have 2 key players out today.
CB - Browns (with Haden out, it's a push)

QB - Steelers - Ben, no doubt, but Hoyer is not Quin, Frye, etc. he is a decent QB. He has a nice TD to Int ratio.
RB - Steelers - Close, but give the edge to the Steelers. Browns b-u RBs did well first time around. Tate is now healthy.
WR - Steelers - With puffer Gordon suspended the Steelers have a clear and decisive advantge.
S - Steelers - not sure here, I give the edge to the Browns.